Recreational opportunities offered in Protected Natural Areas: analysis of the most visited National Parks in Brazil and the United States of America in 2017.

Gomes, Carolina Ribeiro; Figueiredo, Múcio do Amaral; Salvio, Geraldo Majela Moraes

doi:10.14393/SN-v33-2021-58518

Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Brasil

Español English

sumário « anterior atual seguinte »

Sumário

Articles • Soc. nat. 33 • 2021 • https://doi.org/10.14393/SN-v33-2021-58518 copy

Recreational opportunities offered in Protected Natural Areas: analysis of the most visited National Parks in Brazil and the United States of America in 2017.

Authorship SCIMAGO INSTITUTIONS RANKINGS

Abstract

National Parks (NPs) are instruments for nature protection and tourism that demand tools for proper visitation. With the advance of tourism in these areas, NPs assume a double responsibility: to maintain visitor experience quality and to contribute with all their potential to society. In this sense, the Recreation Opportunity Spectrum (ROS) tool categorizes “Visitation Opportunities” classes (Pristine, Primitive, Natural, Rural, and Urban) to identify specific attributes of each environment and each visiting public and, thus, organize tourist use. In this scenario, we aimed to analyze the opportunities offered in 10 National Parks, five in Brazil and five in the United States (US), to understand how different Opportunity Classes can influence tourist visitation. The data were drawn from bibliographic and documentary research. After identifying the tourist potential of each NP, we applied the ROS methodology. The results showed a relationship between the number of opportunities offered and the number of visitors received by the National Parks, confirming the assumption that, both in Brazilian and American parks, different recreational opportunities are related to the largest number of visitors. Thus, the Recreation Opportunity Spectrum (ROS) tool presents itself as an important management tool for tourism visitation. The possibility of creating visitation classes in natural areas must be widely used to guarantee sustainable tourism.

Keywords:
ROS; Management Plan Tourism; Tourism

NATIONAL PARK	BRIEF CHARACTERIZATION AND GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION	TOTAL AREA	YEAR OF CREATION	PUBLIC USE AND VISITATION OPPORTUNITIES
Parque Nacional da Tijuca	Located in Downtown Rio de Janeiro, in the Tijuca mountains, south-central Rio de Janeiro state (RJ), between parallels 22° 55' S and 23° 00' S and meridians 43° 11' W and 43° 19' W. It has a wide touristic structure spread across three sectors (Floresta, Serra da Carioca and Pedra Bonita/Pedra da Gávea). The forest patches are interconnected by trails and buildings.	3.95 thousand hectares	1961	The Park has a touristic structure with more than 150 attractions, 128 km of managed trails for public use, and 52 km of internal roads, besides 69 historical monuments and a visitor center. It comprises both conserved and highly intervened areas, with tourist use across the three sectors. The Corcovado is the Park’s main attraction, concentrating 62% of the total number of visits, followed by the Estrada da Vista Chinesa (Belvedere) (16%) and the Floresta da Tijuca Sector (8%).
Parque Nacional do Iguaçu	Located in the far west Paraná region, 17 km from downtown Foz do Iguaçu, between parallels 25⁰ 04’ S and 25⁰ 41’ S and meridians 53⁰ 58’ W and 25⁰ 04’ W. The Park is situated in the Iguaçu River basin and shares boundaries with 14 municipalities within a 10-km radius.	185.26 thousand hectares	1939	Connected to the Iguazu National Park (Argentina) through the Iguaçu River, the Park integrates the most important biological continuum of central-southern South America. Through joint efforts between Brazil and Argentina, the region ensures the protection and conservation of 600 thousand hectares of protected areas. Its main attraction is the Iguaçu Falls. Its visitation structure is designed for intensive use, with a visitor center and multiple trail options.
Parque Nacional de Jericoacoara	Created after partial recategorization of the Área de Proteção Ambiental de Jericoacoara (Environmental Protection Area), this NP is located in the municipalities of Jijoca de Jericoacoara, Cruz, and Camocim, on the coast of Ceará state, coordinates 2° 47' S and 40° 30' W.	8.85 thousand hectares	2002	The Park has trails, attractions, and sectors dedicated to wind sports. Its main attractions are the beaches, such as Pedra Furada and Serrote, which are largely visited rock formations. Although it lacks a visitor center, the Park provides tours to the mangroves and temporary lagoons. Its headquarters are located in the Jericoacoara village, which is accessed through the municipality of Jijoca de Jericoacoara, through unpaved trails preferably used by four-wheel-drive vehicles and dune buggies.
Parque Nacional Marinho de Fernando de Noronha	Located in the Fernando de Noronha archipelago, 345 km northeast from Cape São Roque, in Rio Grande do Norte state (RN) and 545 km from Recife, Pernambuco state (PE), between coordinates 3°45' 3°56' S and 32°20' W. Comprises 70% of the main island of the Fernando de Noronha archipelago and all other 21 secondary islands, managed in partnership with the Área de Proteção Ambiental de Fernando de Noronha (Environmental Protection Area).	11.27 thousand hectares	1988	The Park has attractions, trails (such as the Baía do Sancho and the Forte de São Joaquim (tourist attractions) a visitor center, and historical sites divided between the terrestrial land the marine parts of the Park. A few islands, such as Rata, Rasa, and Frade, stand out in the archipelago. Each opportunity offers the possibility of activities that include hiking, marine life observation, and rock climbing. In some sections, only boat trips (and no diving) are allowed. Vessels travel at a reduced speed under permanent inspection. The archipelago has a structure for hosting services that cater to different types of audiences.
Parque Nacional de Brasília	Located in the northwest portion of Distrito Federal (Brazil’s Federal District), approximately 10 km from downtown Brasília, between coordinates 15° 38' 28" S and 48° 1' 15" W. Its creation is directly related to the construction of the Federal Capital, due to an agreement between the Ministério da Agricultura (Ministry of Agriculture) and the NOVA CAP - Companhia de Desenvolvimento da Nova Capital (Company for the Development of the New Capital) for, among other tasks, “proposing and creating new forest reserves and stations” in the Distrito Federal. The Park comprises the administrative regions of Brasília, Sobradinho and Brazlândia, and the municipality of Padre Bernardo (Goiás State).	42,39 thousand hectares	1961	The Park offers several activities for public use, with emphasis on the “Mineral Water” pools (terminology used by the public to identify the park). The most attractive places for leisure in the Park are the swimming pools, particularly the Old Pool. Other attractions include the Environmental Education Center and walking and cycling trails. The Park has a visitor center.

NATIONAL PARK	BRIEF CHARACTERIZATION AND GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION	TOTAL AREA	YEAR OF CREATION	PUBLIC USE AND VISITATION OPPORTUNITIES
Great Smoky Mountains National Park	Located in the western US region between the states of Tennessee and North Carolina, coordinates 37°11′02″N and 108°29′19″W. One of the largest PAs in the United States.	203 thousand hectares	1934	The Park has areas that allow a range of activities. It preserves 160 historic buildings and structures and maintains 25 trails spread over 800 km with different characteristics for different publics. It allows activities such as cycling, fishing, hiking, horseback riding, waterfall visits, historic tours, and wildlife observation. It also has an information center, three visitor centers, campgrounds, and several feeding, transport, and accommodation areas.
Grand Canyon National Park	This NP is located in the Grand Canyon region of Arizona, between coordinates 36º 6' 3" N and 112º 5' 26" W. The steep canyon that lends its name to the park was formed by the Colorado River and is 446 km long, 29 km wide, and 1.6 km deep.	492.6 thousand hectares	1919	The Park contains two sectors: the South Rim and the North Rim. The South Rim is open to visitors year-round and provides access to Desert View, Hermits Rest, and Grand Canyon Village, a distinctive complex with attractions, activities, and a transportation service. The North Rim is less accessible and closed to visitors between May and October, during the northern hemisphere winter. The Park’s main attraction, the Grand Canyon, attracts millions of visitors. It also has three visitor centers, a museum, an information center, and visitation areas with accommodation and food services.
Zion National Park	Located in southwestern Utah, between coordinates 37° 12' 00.3" N and 112° 59' 12.9" W. On July 31^st, 1909, incumbent president William H. Taft issued a proclamation that reserved 15,200 hectares as the Mukuntuweap National Monument. In 1918, another presidential proclamation expanded the monument to 31,080 hectares. In 1919, the US Congress established the area as a National Park. In 1937, another National Monument called the Kolob Canyons was created. In 1956, the US Congress annexed this monument to the NP.	60.1 thousand hectares	1919	The Park offers trails with different types of access and levels of difficulty and attractions for birdwatching and wildlife observation. It has two visitor centers, a human history museum, campgrounds, and several trail options. In addition, Zion Lodge has tourist accommodation and food services, gift shops, and a post office.
Rocky Mountain National Park	Located in Colorado state. The Park’s structure is divided into five regions: Region 1 or West Side; Region 2 or Alpine, with accessible trails and lookouts; Region 3 or North Side; Region 4, the central and most visited area of the park, with easily accessible trails; and Region 5 or South Side, which contains the Estes Park/Longs Peak and multiple waterfalls.	107.55 thousand hectares	1915	The Park offers attractions and recreational activities that include hiking, scenic trails, wildlife observation, fishing, environmental education programs, and horseback riding. It offers over 130 trail options along 482 km;5 campgrounds; 5 visitor centers; 1 information center, and 1 historical museum. The Park has campgrounds but no hotels or inns.
Yosemite National Park	Located in the Sierra Nevada Mountains, California, USA, in Mariposa and Tuolumne counties.	308.1 thousand hectares	1890	The Park has attractions and activities spread over 2,600 km of watercourses, 560 km of roads, and 1,300 km of trails that are open to visitors. The main tourist attraction of the Park, the “Yosemite Valley”, encompasses 18 km² of the Park’s total area.

Opportunity Class	Documentary analysis	Class attributes
Pristine	Are there zones with a high degree of naturalness; difficult access; no infrastructure or human intervention; little evidence of recreational activities?	Visitation with a Low Degree of Intervention. High naturalness and integrity of the ecological processes; little evidence of human activities and low probability of encountering other people. The access is difficult, the level of challenges and risks taken by visitors is high and the presence of roads or motorized activities is uncommon.
Primitive	Are there visitation zones with a still high degree of naturalness but with the possibility of access by vehicles and a minimum structure for tourist activity?	Visitation with an Intermediate Degree of Intervention. High naturalness and integrity of the ecological processes; little evidence of human activity. Access trails that should be accompanied by guides; many areas without defined trails; little infrastructure; offers visitors with the opportunity to experience autonomy, solitude, and challenges.
Natural	Are there zones with easily accessible tourist activities, defined trails, tourist infrastructure, campgrounds, and visitor centers?	Visitation with a High Degree of Intervention. The environment has natural characteristics and human activities may take place; the landscape has natural and cultural attributes; access may be motorized or on foot through well-defined trails; encounters and interactions with other visitors are frequent; support infrastructure is planned for intensive visitor use, with information boards and signs; self-guided trails are allowed. This class includes visitor centers and camping areas.
Rural	Are there zones with local communities adjacent to the buffer zone, accessible by roads or rural trails that enable experience with the local way of life and interaction between locals and visitors?	Visitation with a High Degree of Intervention. Comprises natural areas and rural settlements adjacent to the conservation unit’s buffer zone. Access is via rural roads and trails that connect the properties to the unit’s boundaries; may offer services to appreciate the local culture, practices, and way of life in the region. There is the possibility of interaction between the local population and visitors. The infrastructure is usually simple and rustic.
Urban	Are there zones with a developed commercial or administrative structure for tourism; visible interventions with a predominant human presence and food, parking, and lodging facilities?	Visitation with a High Degree of Intervention. The environment is characterized by a mix of commercial and tourist uses; the area offers tourist services that include transportation, hotels, multiple restaurants, hospitals, and frequent encounters with people from different origins.

National Parks investigated		Number of visits in 2017
Brazil	Tijuca	3.300.000
	Iguaçu	1.788.922
	Jericoacoara	780.000
	Marinho de Fernando de Noronha	389.744
	Brasília	265.518
	Total	6.524.184
United States	Great Smoky Mountains	11.388.893
	Grand Canyon	6.254.238
	Zion	4.504.812
	Rocky Mountain	4.437.215
	Yosemite	4.336.890
	Total	30.922.048

NATIONAL PARKS	OPPORTUNITY CLASSES
NATIONAL PARKS	PRISTINE	PRIMITIVE	NATURAL	RURAL	URBAN
TIJUCA	31 visitation areas (50% of the park’s total area).	Seven visitation areas (with access trails).	264 visitation areas. A visitor’s center; 153 attractions; 128 km of trails.	Three visitation areas (access points to the neighborhoods adjacent to the park).	28 visitation areas (among restaurants, snack bars, picnic areas, parking lots, and gift shops).
IGUAÇU	Three visitation areas (60% of the park’s total area).	12 visitation areas (primitive trails).	Nine visitation areas (a visitor’s center; four main trails; five attractions).	Four visitation areas (access trails to adjacent municipalities).	Three visitation areas (administration, Porto Canoa station, and food court).
JERICOACOARA	-	Four visitation areas (primitive trails).	26 visitation areas (two sectors for wind sports; 17 attractions; seven trails). Does not have a visitor center.	Eight visitation areas (access trails to villages and settlements adjacent to the park’s boundary).	Four visitation areas (guarded entrance gates for access control and visitor registration).
FERNANDO DE NORONHA	Four visitation areas (monitoring and scientific research)	10 visitation areas (boat trip sites).	34 visitation areas (eight trails; 19 attractions; six historic sites; one visitor center).	12 visitation areas (access to surrounding villages and historic sites).	Five visitation areas; 102 accommodation options in the archipelago only.
BRASÍLIA	Four visitation areas (scientific research).	15 visitation areas (surrounding the pristine zone).	Seven visitation areas (a visitor center; trails and attractions).	Two visitation areas (access roads to neighboring municipalities).	Eight visitation areas (restaurants, cafeteria, medical center, bicycle rack, support center, and headquarters).

NATIONAL PARKS	OPPORTUNITY CLASSES
NATIONAL PARKS	PRISTINE	PRIMITIVE	NATURAL	RURAL	URBAN
GRAND CANYON	Nine visitation areas. (“Wild” trails and research areas).	4 visitation areas (primitive trails).	21 visitation areas (three visitor centers; a museum; an information center; 11 trails; Desert View).	Two visitation areas (Desert View Drive and access to the Grand Canyon Village), activities and transportation center.	Seven visitation areas. Information center, restrooms, parking lot, picnic areas, and access to several trails; lodging and restaurants; Grand Canyon Lodge and Grand Canyon Village.
ZION	One visitation area (Zion Wilderness).	Two visitation areas (Zion Wilderness - Backpacking; Timber Creek Overlook Trail).	24 visitation areas (two visitor centers; a museum; three campgrounds; 18 trails).	1 visitation area. South Road - Access to the town of Springdale	4 visitation areas (food and lodging areas). Zion Lodge (opportunity to provide numerous tourist services).
ROCKY MOUNTAINS	Three visitation areas (Specimen Mountain, West Creek, and Paradise Park).	Four visitation areas (Bear Lake, Wild Basin, Longs Peak, Agnes-Vaille).	142 visitation areas (five camping areas; five visitor centers; an information center; a historic museum; 130 trails).	Four visitation areas (trails with a tourist structure that support two roads; they offer access to the surrounding municipalities: Grand Lake and Estes Park).	19 visiting areas. Unlike the other American parks studied, Rocky Mountain does not have hotels or inns, only campgrounds.
YOSEMITE	-	Two visitation areas (Half Dome Trail and John Muir Trail).	22 visitation areas (three visitor centers; Wilderness Center; Museum; Art and Nature Center; Conservation Center; Yosemite’s History Center; Hill’s Studio; 13 campgrounds).	Four visitation areas (Yosemite Valley; Wawona and Mariposa Grove; Tuolumne Meadows; and Tioga Road). These areas have particular communities that offer tourism practices.	15 visitation areas (lodging sites, food services, picnic areas, and restrooms)

Editora da Universidade Federal de Uberlândia - EDUFU Av. João Naves de Ávila, 2121 - Bloco 5M Sala 302B, 38400902 - Uberlândia - Minas Gerais - Brasil, +55 (34) 3239- 4549 - Uberlândia - MG - Brazil
E-mail: sociedade.natureza@ig.ufu.br

Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS

[1] AUTHORS' CONTRIBUTION

Carolina Ribeiro Gomes conceived the study, analyzed the data and wrote the text. Múcio do Amaral Figueiredo supervised the study, analyzed the data, worked on the writing and revision of the text Geraldo Majela Moraes Salvio co-supervised the study, analyzed the data, worked on the writing and revision of the text.